These Incredible Restaurants and Bars Have Australia’s Best Wine Lists
The annual Australia’s Wine List of the Year Awards continue to turn the spotlight on the country’s most skilful sommeliers and restaurateurs — and the wine and beverage lists they create. Whether you’re after a dazzling array of sparkling or an innovative range of world-class sake, these award-winning venues have been selected by an expert panel of judges that includes five Master Sommeliers and five Masters of Wine. Pouring top drops by the glass, plus sake, beer and cocktails, these are the best places to enjoy a drink around Australia.
Image credit: Sharyn Cairns
Australia’s Wine List of the Year: Gimlet at Cavendish House, Melbourne, Vic
1/23On the surface, the wine list at Gimlet at Cavendish House, led by wine buyer and head sommelier Anthony Pieri, is an objectively excellent collection. Spanning almost 60 pages, it’s immediately clear that its author has a deep and lasting love for champagne – an entire page is devoted to the vintages of Jacques Selosse (“Peerless,” the menu notes admiringly) and the buoyant cuvées of Cédric Bouchard are also afforded plenty of real estate. Outstanding Australian producers, such as Tasmania’s Tolpuddle and Victoria’s Crawford River, are highlighted with the same reverence as the greatest Burgundian estates. The by-the-glass list is generous and intriguing, allowing the curious to explore exceptional drops that they might otherwise never encounter (including various champagnes and still wines that you can usually only order by the bottle).
“It’s a list with high appeal for all wine-lovers, outstanding in its breadth, depth, balance and originality,” says judge Andrew Graham. “Driven by a mantra of ‘discovery, familiarity, value and experience’, it artfully blends the great and the good with a dose of variety and complexity.”
According to Pieri, this list is about the people who helped create it. “I have a fantastic team,” he says. Winning the Australia’s Wine List of the Year Awards Best Wine List Victoria in 2023 galvanised the crew of six to push the offering forward. “We would stay late, come in early,” says Pieri. “There were disagreements and there was angst and it wasn’t always easy but we did it.” Empowering his sommeliers and allowing them to express their creativity has become Pieri’s raison d’être. “Our list is a product of all those people, all our conversations. We’re all so proud of it.”
Gimlet at Cavendish House is also the winner of Best Wine List Victoria, Best City Restaurant, the Sommeliers’ Choice Award and the Judy Hirst Award for the sommelier responsible for the winning list, Anthony Pieri.
Best Wine List NSW: Monopole, Sydney
2/23Monopole co-owner Nick Hildebrandt has been sitting on such an impressive array of French wines for so long that it was fitting to adjust the menu to match. Recently, the food has evolved from generalised wine bar small plates to unashamedly French offerings, including pot-au-feu and steak au poivre. “The 1981 Château Montrose or 1997 Trimbach Frédéric Emile by the glass has to appeal to wine-lovers,” says judge Ken Gargett. They certainly blend beautifully with this Sydney stalwart’s new direction.
Monopole is also the winner of Best Wine Bar List – the Fiona Macdonald Award
Best Wine List SA: The Salopian Inn, McLaren Vale
3/23McLaren Vale’s historic Salopian Inn, known for its ingredient-focused cooking, takes out three major awards this year. The reasons, according to judge Nicole Bilson, include a commitment to “captivating wines to suit every budget”, along with a substantial by-the-glass list that “invites discovery, with quirky varieties and regions from Australia and abroad”.
The Salopian Inn is also the winner of Best Listing of a Region’s Wines and Best Country Restaurant Wine List
Best Wine List Tasmania: Molto, Hobart
4/23Another multiple winner, Molto is a warm and welcoming wine bar modelled on a classic enoteca that serves up a weekly rotating menu of modern European food. Hyper-local Tassie producers feature prominently on this list but you might also run into a classic Alsatian wine of note or a Burgundy that stops you in your tracks. “You can never be too sure what you might come across here; the excitement and the discovery factor is high,” says judge Jeni Port.
Molto is also the winner of Best Listing of Tasmanian Wines
Best Wine List Queensland: Agnes, Fortitude Valley
5/23Fire-fuelled Agnes has coal-roasted proteins at its heart but wine is an equal to the food; in fact, guests get a peek into the huge glass-walled cellar as soon as they enter the venue. Diners might start their meal with what judge Jane Faulkner calls “one of the country’s most diverse and enticing by-the-glass selections” before diving into the thoughtful and exploratory 20-plus-page bottle range.
Best Wine List WA: Gibney, Cottesloe
6/23This newcomer isn’t content with wowing its guests with flamboyant tableside service and Malibu-meets-Mediterranean vibes; wine is also a serious drawcard. Though it only opened in May, this suave seaside eatery’s list has what judge Gargett calls a “complexity and breadth that suggests it’s been years in the making”.
Gibney is also the winner of Best New Wine List – the Tony Hitchin Award
Best Wine List ACT: Capitol Bar & Grill, Canberra
7/23Canberra’s QT Hotel is more than vibrant guestrooms and wry, politics-themed décor. It’s also the home of fine steakhouse Capitol Bar & Grill, which in turn contains a joyful celebration of local wines. The list features “a sparkling collection of winemakers, styles and years”, according to judge Port, who recommends trying the Women of Canberra Wine Flight and exploring the region’s famous rieslings and shiraz.
Capitol Bar & Grill is also the winner of Best Listing of ACT Wines
Best Club Restaurant Wine List: Junction Moama, Moama, NSW
8/23“An impressive selection bursting with sophistication,” says judge Gargett of this anything-but-expected list. The strong carafe and by-the-glass program pairs perfectly with the local producer-focused menu at Moama Bowling Club, just steps away from the mighty Murray.
Best Pub Restaurant Wine List: The Crafers Hotel, Crafers, SA
9/23“Many a tourist has stumbled upon The Crafers Hotel expecting a local pub, instead discovering a wine wonderland with a cellar of over 1400 listings,” says judge Bilson of the historic Adelaide Hills tavern. There’s a French tilt to the food menu so much of the list leans in a similar direction – the Burgundy collection is a jawdropper – but there’s an enviable Aussie showing as well, particularly from South Australia.
Best Hotel Restaurant Wine List: Woodcut, Barangaroo, NSW
10/23Heartfelt, fire-cooked proteins are at the core of Ross and Sunny Lusted’s restaurant in the Crown Sydney complex but the wine list is a powerful supporting act. “For the third year, Addy Lam and the team have produced a wine list to thrill and dazzle,” says judge Peter Forrestal. The beautifully balanced range pays equal attention to old-world masters and up-and-comers.
Best List of Wines by the Glass: Jonah’s, Whale Beach, NSW
11/23You might think that a visit to glamorous Jonah’s on Sydney’s Northern Beaches (arrive by seaplane for maximum impact) is all about enjoying the view and the confident, Italian-focused menu. But there are plenty more treasures to be found in the by-the-glass selection. “Many mature options and plenty of left-field choices as well,” says judge Gargett. “A thrilling list.”
Best Food & Wine Matching List and Best Non-Alcoholic List: Restaurant Botanic, Adelaide, SA
12/23The hardest decision to make when dining at this ambitious eatery inside Adelaide’s Botanic Garden is whether to pair your multi-course menu with something from the extensive wine library or the impressive non-alcoholic list of juices, teas and ferments. “Little wonder it won two awards,” says judge Bilson.
Image credit: Circl Wine House
Best Champagne List: Circl Wine House, Melbourne, Vic
13/23“An ultra-fine collection of champagne,” says judge Mike Bennie of the bubbles selection – many of which are available by the glass or in large format – at this impressive new Melbourne wine bar. It’s a credit to head sommelier Xavier Vigier, formerly of Ten Minutes by Tractor.
Image credit: Nikki To
Best Sparkling Wine List: Quay, The Rocks, NSW
14/23There are no weak categories at Sydney harbourside jewel Quay, according to judge Port. But the list of sparkling wines positively demands your attention. “It is truly that good.”
Quay is also the winner of Best Listing of New Zealand Wines
Image credit: Kitti Gould
Best Wine List (50 Wines): Bar Lucia, Potts Point, NSW
15/23Potts Point has welcomed a vibrant slice of Madrid in this spirited wine bar. Spanish labels dominate, naturally, but sommelier Kasia Sobiesiak also trains her focus on global and local women winemakers. “Low-intervention wines, organic and biodynamic, are scattered throughout this well-priced list that excites on so many levels,” says judge Port.
Image credit: Tourism Tasmania
Best Wine List (100 Wines): Institut Polaire, Hobart, Tas
16/23This chic little wine bar might be famous for its ice-cold dry Martini but there’s a gorgeous wine list working just as hard as the spirits. Cool-climate drops are the focal point – as befits the theme of the bar and its location – as is a celebration of “the artisanal, the family-owned and the sustainable”, says judge Port.
Best Wine List (200 Wines): Poodle Bar & Bistro, Fitzroy, Vic
17/23“Pulling together a tight list requires an artful hand and the offering at Poodle feels extremely well-picked at every turn,” says judge Graham. There is plenty that leans lo-fi at this design-led Melbourne bar and bistro but it avoids falling into what Graham calls “excess esoterica”. The sparkling selection is particularly exciting, especially the collection of bubbly reds.
Image credit: Steven Woodburn
Best Aperitif List and Best Digestif List: Bentley Restaurant + Bar, Sydney, NSW
18/23“One of the few lists that can stop you in its tracks, such is its brilliance,” says judge Port of Nick Hildebrandt’s labour of love at his and Brent Savage’s CBD fine-diner. The start and finish of your exploration are well-served by the stunning aperitifs and digestifs to select from.
Best Sake List: Leonie Upstairs, South Carlton, Vic
19/23“The integration of the Japanese-inspired menu and the sake list is admirable, as is its singular approach,” says judge Peter Bourne of the extensive rice wine collection at Leonie Upstairs. The flights are considered and educational.
Image credit: Frances Andrijich
Best Beer List: Mojo’s Kitchen, Bar & Bottleshop, Bunbury, WA
20/23The beer list at this multi-space beauty is impressive: Belgium, Canada, Scandinavia, Italy and England are all represented. It will, says judge Gargett, “astound” even the most well-travelled palate.
Best Cocktail List: Noosa Waterfront, Noosaville, Qld
21/23A well-crafted Italian menu, views over the river and excellent wines are just the beginning at Noosa Waterfront. The cocktail list is where things get really exciting, especially the options in the imaginative Gin and Tonic Experience section.
Australia’s Choice Award – As Voted by You: The Dry Dock, Balmain, NSW
22/23Pub reimaginings are nothing new but few have nailed the heritage-meets-modern brief as well as The Dry Dock in Sydney’s Balmain, which opened under the stewardship of hospo veterans James Ingram and Mike Everett late last year. Come for chef Ben Sitton’s flame-grilled steaks or a prawn sandwich in the lounge and stay for the well-appointed wine list. A collaboration between head sommelier Christiane Poulos (formerly of Rockpool and Bennelong) and wine consultant John Clancy, it’s a rich collection that seamlessly blends the domestic and international. The by-the-glass choice is particularly impressive, allowing diners to explore as far away as Burgundy and Tuscany or as close to home as the Mornington Peninsula and Adelaide Hills.